Honestly, I’m pretty open about settings. I have a soft spot for high fantasy stuff for sure (as you can tell from my personal art) but I have a lot of respect for nicely design sci-fi or science fantasy settings. I like the design work of FF7 a lot, not really because it’s scifantasy but because it’s diesel punk and I love that stuff too. I thought the design work for FF13 was balls to the walls shite so… make of that what you will. My fave general world design stuff has been stuff like FF12 and tactics. I don’t really love zelda because it’s fantasy, but because it’s fun world building and I love puzzle games. I wouldn’t be turned off a modern or sci-fi zelda game unless the game itself wasn’t very good.
That said, if my options for my fave types of games aren’t being limited to fantasy and science fantasy and have to generalize genre, my fave types of games are psychological and horror games. I’m a huge old-school silent hill fan :B